Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hello_hny 1269 days ago
You don't know if the unique ball is heavier or lighter, how would this work?
1 comments

Ah, if you need to know that for certain then you'd be restricted to 18 balls (6,6,6), (2,2,2), (1,1). Otherwise I guess you would "only" know in 26/27 cases if it was heavier or lighter (off the balance in all 3 conditions).

....and now I understand, you would only initially know there is a difference in weight, not which side had the heavier or lighter ball.

No, you can't solve the harder version with 18 balls, as you just proved.

18 balls have 36>27 states.