Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by DoItToMe81 1272 days ago
Some of this article is poorly researched. Rocket.chat is not moving over to the protocol, it's just implementing federation in such a way that Rocket.Chat servers can communicate with Matrix servers. It's still its own (heavily flawed) thing.
3 comments

But at least their clients aren't awful, might actually be useful if it can talk matrix
What makes you think it’s flawed?
what's the difference?
Personally, I think it’s fine to say that X speaks Matrix if X speaks the Server-Server API, like Rocket.Chat or Gitter does.

I think the distinction the grandparent post is making is that RC doesn’t speak the Client-Server API, so you can’t point a random Matrix client at it. Honestly, I think it matters more that you can talk to it transparently via the Matrix network than connect your favourite Matrix client to it.

Well, you can't simply use Rocket.Chat to join a Matrix server. You need to join a Rocket.Chat server set up to communicate with Matrix and work from there. Neither can you use a Matrix client to join a Rocket.Chat instance.