Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by maria2 1272 days ago
Are you sure? Just some back of the napkin math: S&P 500 is 5.17 times higher since the bottom of 08. BRKB is 6 times higher. And performance this year is even more dramatic. S&P is down 20%. BRKB is up 3%. In 08, too, the decline in Berkshire was much less than the S&P. Clearly Berkshire has been a better bet at most points in time.
1 comments

December 2008 to Dec 2022, I am getting SP500 at 13.5% and BRK-B at 12%:

https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/

https://dqydj.com/stock-return-calculator/

Dec 2007 to Dec 2022 is 8.86% for SP500 vs 7.99% for BRK-B.

Dec 1997 is 7.7% for SP500 vs 10.57% for BRK-B.

BRK even provides this information by year in their annual report on page 2, and the all time record is BRK at 20% versus SP500 at 10%:

https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/2021ltr.pdf?mod=ar...

Of course, I should not debate that it is possible to beat the market, but the question for an individual is, is the potential return over the relatively risk-less SP500 worth the risk? And the data for the past 14 years or so indicates that BRK’s edge may have decreased.

I write “relatively risk-less SP500” because on a sufficiently long timeline, I assume US federal government is bailing out SP500, or the US federal government has big problems (such as does not exist in the form it is in now).