Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hyung 5284 days ago
The pressure to censor content often comes from advertisers. A lot of advertisers don't want their ads showing up next to photos with even minimally offensive content.

(This doesn't explain everything for Google, but I'm sure it was a factor.)
2 comments
earbitscom 5284 days ago
I used to work at an affiliate network where an advertiser's ad ended up next to a satirical video for "Tourette syndrome Barbie". Some national Tourette syndrome organization called the advertiser and threatened to boycott them. They pulled the entire campaign from us, despite our ability to make sure this particular affiliate would never promote the ad again. Long story short, knee jerk chain reactions are the norm. Advocacy group or other consumer group overreacts, advertiser is forced to overreact to avoid a boycott or press incident, publisher gets screwed out of a good campaign, picture of guy flipping off nobody is banned forever.

In other words, you're half-right. Don't blame Google. But probably don't blame advertisers either. Blame some overly sensitive consumer group or advocacy group for having no sense of humor and throwing their weight around because they have nothing better to do.

link
4ad 5284 days ago
Google maximizes profit satisfying advertisers in my personal detriment. Of course I can blame Google for that. I never care about businesses making money, I only care about my personal comfort and welfare.
link
hahainternet 5284 days ago
Lets be clear here, we're talking about Google removing a particular picture with an offensive gesture shown.

This is not to the detriment of your personal comfort or welfare. Please stop hamming this up beyond the reality of the situation. Google run a private service and while they should not censor political speech or genuine opinion, they certainly have the right to determine what they consider offensive.

link
vm 5284 days ago
It's okay for Google to make their site advertiser-safe.

It's not okay for Google to delete the image, without warning or notification to the user. They could have easily reset his profile pic to null and sent him a note.

link