Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by aurbano 1279 days ago
This has probably been said many times before - but it also seems like a new era for digital surveillance or espionage: bots could "befriend" humans, create full networks of fake people crafting any story imaginable in order to extract information. Maybe
1 comments

More possibly, the domain most improved by real-time English chat will be phone scams.
I was thinking "recruitment for cults / terrorist groups." In 5 years, whenever someone seems lonely on the internet, a "friend" will magically materialize and sympathetically listen to their problems. Gradually the "friend" will start turning the conversation to their goals. ("Oh, your girlfriend left you? That sucks... but do you know who's REALLY to blame for all your problems?")

And there are a lot of lonely people out there...

This isn't likely IMO. It's not like there's a robust API to find "lonely people" in the first place, and the difficulty in creating sympathetic people to talk to for a long period of time without slipping up once will be immensely hard. What if they want to voice chat, or play a video game?

Also, don't cults have a massive surplus of people-time as is? I get the feeling that, if I wanted to go and join a cult, it's not like they would tell me they were short-staffed and there was a waiting list.

More likely (and mundane) outcome is that people use it to create cheap online therapy services. Good ROI, clearly defined goals, very large addressable market, easier to find people willing to work on it.

Well, I hope I'm wrong! ;-)

My guess is that it'll be like "Nigerian prince" scams: it's not all that convincing. But even if it only works on 0.1% of its targets, that's still a large absolute number of people.

That would also be the case for just spamming people with "go join our cult" links, and I haven't seen this once. The limits load on other things:

- Local presence of the cult

- Ability to operationalize victims (convince them to do terrorism, in your model)

- Ability of victims to "function" in society (hold down a job, do cult administrative stuff, earn money)

For an idea of what is the upper bound, look at Scientology or Jehovah's Witnesses. They don't have to use an AI to talk to people, they just hand out fliers on the street and talk to whoever is interested. Lonely people already today can sign up for Scientology, so the AI adds nothing.

luckily for us, most have learned to not even answer the phone after the past 5 years on unending call spam.