Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by miles_matthias 5287 days ago
I couldn't agree with this more. My grandma recently bought one and I spend all of Christmas getting it set up for her and teaching her. She's gotten really frustrated and would probably return it if it hadn't been free from her company.

This part especially is what I agree with:

"Yet, the drive to quickly release a product in a hot field is almost irresistible. Amazon believes growing marketshare is more important than the reputation of their tablet. This is wrong. I believe consumer tolerance for poor products is at an all time low, thanks to ten years of amazing Apple products. Unfortunately, the idea that first movers win is widely believed across the tech industry."

Version 1.0 should be magical.

I do need to correct the author on one point though - I did find a native email client on it.

2 comments

> "I do need to correct the author on one point though - I did find a native email client on it."

Which is nigh unusable. I set up my email account on it and went to bed with it at 70% charge. I woke up with the Kindle Fire at 20%. It drained 50% in about 8-9 hours doing nothing more than email.

Yes, idle email checking uses power, but I have never seen it that bad on any device. The battery is no slouch either based on normal reading/video drain rates.

My Fire's battery has been dry for 4 weeks and counting now. I have no felt even the slightest urge to recharge it and use it. Considering this is a low-margin device designed to hook people onto Amazon's profitable content pipeline, this is an utter and abject failure. Others I know who got the Fire at launch have all either returned it, or their Fires have a fate similar to mine - forgotten in a drawer.

Yea I didn't say it was good, but it's there. I had a similarly terrible experience with their mail client.
> She's gotten really frustrated and would probably return it if it hadn't been free from her company.

Is this actually a problem with the Fire though, or would she react the same way to an iPad?

Good question. She hasn't used an iPad so I can't fairly compare to that. The Fire's touch motions were tough for me though too at times so I'm assuming she would have an easier time with an iPad. That might not be a fair assumption though. Next time I see her I'll have her try an iPad.