Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bombcar 1286 days ago
The problem comes when those type of bridges don't collapse the first time someone overloads them; then people start using it because "eh it works" and eventually it fails.
1 comments

Is there some well established way to make some very visible but not structural part of a bridge to collapse after an overload, to scare people and make them report the problem?
You probably could, but the amount of engineering and cost required would be simpler to just replace the bridge with a stronger one.

Often these "car only" country bridges are just some large wooden beams over a creek; even a simple concrete culvert replacement would be truck-proof.

Some of them do things like this: https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-small-car-suv-crossing-the...

A really simple catch all, that isn't quite accurate for all cases would be to put a sign over the top of such a bridge,that limits the height of vehicles crossing, excluding trucks with the tall trailers. Would not work for loads that aren't tall though.
I would have thought a few strain gauges, maybe some logic to filter false positives (if that's a risk) and a light would do a reasonable job.
Wait until you see the known issues and reports on bridges in the US that did collapse. Nobody monitors this stuff even on important ones.