Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by osigurdson 1291 days ago
Why is this NK apologist post getting upvoted? Anyone who thinks dictatorships like this are fine should move there and become citizens.
3 comments

Pointing out obvious propaganda is being an "apologist" and supports dictatorships?
> It's not like North Korea is paradise. It's certainly not. It's another poor third world nation, not unlike many of the ones currently on the western side of things where the same sort of life happens.

There's pointing out propaganda (which I agree Radio Free Asia is), and there's boiling down a country well-documented as a known human rights violator[1] to "just another poor third world nation"

[1] https://reliefweb.int/attachments/838602f4-8043-3da8-85bd-12...

No; the apology is in the last paragraph where the poster attempts to suggest that the DPRK is not really any worse than many other countries in the rest of the world.
> Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead.

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

Maybe it’s fine for you to be ok with lying but it’s generally frowned upon.
Sorry, who is lying? Being supportive of any dictator (including Xi) is anti-human.
The problem with extremist takes like yours, is they remove any nuance, to the point of covering for other equally "anti-human" acts that eventually pop up.

Take the falun gong cult, or Scientology of the east for instance.

They were protected and given special status in New York and now spend a large amount of their time spreading nonsense propaganda about not just China but supporting extremists right wing parties globally.

No one in the US even bothered to cover them until they were banned for trying to spend 20millon on pro-trump ads in 2020.

And guess what they own most of the leading YouTube channels about China and are the gateway to anyone curious about how China functions.

I'll know, since I was watching one of their channels since 2010 and only found how how much fake made up stuff they made up only much later.

Same thing happened with how ISIS was formed due to the sheer ignorance of the decision makers.

ignorance breeds stupidity.

If you like dictatorial regimes, please state it plainly.
Go spread your thinly veiled propaganda elsewhere.

Even the mods notice how blatantly bullshit the post was and flagged it.

What is my thinly veiled propaganda? I think NK sucks (not the people but the government naturally).
If you support lying and propaganda, please state it plainly