Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ellie42 5291 days ago
Will GitHub boycott GoDaddy because of their support for SOPA?
1 comments

That would be great. Maybe there should be a new open source software license featuring total denial of rights to use to the MPAA/RIAA member companies too.
No, that would be bad. If open, it should allow everyone. The goal is to unite not segregate after all.
The goal is to unite not segregate after all

Who says that? Why should you unite with your enemy?

Basic of free speech means allowing hateful stuff too. The more you forbid the less free it is (whatever "it" is).
allowing is not the same as supporting
It's not about enemies, it's about free software as a matter of liberty.
"killing with kindness"

"Embrace, extend and extinguish"

There's probably a few in Art of War too.

Although I agree with these goals of such a move (fighting SOPA) such a licence would not be considered an open source or free software licence by the OSI or FSF. A licence must not discriminate based on endeavour.
such a licence would not be considered an open source or free software licence by the OSI or FSF.

So what? What's the downside of using a variation of a common license that is not approved of by the OSI or FSF?

Someone other than the target excluded group might not use the software you're offering for free?

Who would get mad if I released code under the MIT license (or some variant) with an additional requirement that it cannot be used to build Web sites the advocate killing abortion doctors?

If it's my code can't I just set whatever conditions I want (modulo the requirements of any prior licenses my code may be bound by)?

Oh yes, you can release your code under whatever licence you like. The problem with not using an Open Source Licence or Free Software Licence is that it's harder for other people to build on your work, and your work might not be included in distributions of free software (e.g. Debian).
The closest I could think of is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CrimethInc._N%C2%A9!_license. But I think I'll stick with the GPL and WTFPL.