Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by giobox 1292 days ago
The problem is the Verge's arguments do hold some water. Its not just a 49 dollar rental - its 49 dollars with a mandatory hold on a credit card of the full replacement value.

Many iPhone owners will not have a credit card (especially in Europe), let alone a credit card with a credit limit capable of holding thousands of dollars even if it's temporary. It's also a risk some people on lower incomes simply will not want to take. The tools Apple send are so over-engineered for the task at hand, the replacement value is enormous relative to the task.

> https://www.selfservicerepair.com/tool-kit-rental

When NYT tried, 49 dollar rental fee, 1210 dollar hold. 1210 dollar CC hold just to replace a battery is crazy when independent stores across the USA do it with third party tools costing a fraction of this just fine every day. Apple's right to repair efforts arguably verges on a parody of a right to repair at times - cellphones should not need a holding deposit significantly larger than renting a car for the same period of time to replace a $79 battery. If Apple's motivations are genuine, the full replacement hold could arguably become a lower insurance hold fee just like a car rental often does.

If you want to look to a company renting for 7 days expensive, heavy, complex technical equipment - I think lensrentals.com does a great job renting equipment costing tens of thousands of dollars and Apple's repair program could learn a lot.

> https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/25/technology/personaltech/a....

> https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/faq/