Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by frippertronics 1285 days ago
I don't think it's valid to write off all unions based on anecdotal evidence. For every example of bad unionisation one can probably provide one or more counter-examples of good unionisation (e.g. the Scandinavian countries).
2 comments

Well, yes, but if there's a one-to-one correspondence between good unions and bad unions,that pretty much implies that the expected value of a union vote is zero. It's just the same as not unionizing.

In my personal anecdotal experience, the unions at the places I've worked have been mired in factions. They supported some workers but not others because they picked sides. They weren't just neutral, they undermined some workers to benefit others. It really soured me on them.

Weren't the Teamsters also super corrupt?

(My only knowledge comes from watching The Irishman)

There was corruption at the height of organized crime. The average Teamster is doing a lot better than than average non-unionized trucker
Philly roofers union firebombed my grandfathers truck beacuse he was non-union.
Oh yeah big time. The entire east coast got it's strings pulled by the unions.