Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by denton-scratch 1303 days ago
XDG is a specification of Free Desktop, a body that I don't trust. Standardizing filesystem locations can't be a bad thing; but an awful lot of it is tied into the requirements of GNOME Desktop, a project which seems to be trying to rule the world, and which I don't want to help with.

Perhaps if XDG were cut loose from the Free Desktop project, more developers and maintainers would pay more attention to it.
1 comments
Joker_vD 1303 days ago
That's one reason. Another reason is that while some effort was spent on writing this spec, apparently (?) almost no effort was spent on promoting/enforcing it: there is another top-level comment in this thread from a 10-year Linux application developer that says they've learned about XDG from this very post.

And indeed, there are lots of tremendously popular apps out there (Slack, for instance) that use e.g. $HOME/Downloads as a default download directory instead of $(xdg-user-dir DOWNLOAD), and most users don't mind.

link
forgotpwd16 1302 days ago
Because '$HOME/Downloads' is the default for `xdg-user-dir DOWNLOAD` and most users never change it.
link
Joker_vD 1302 days ago
Only in English locales. Although yes, most users are in that locale.
link