[mach1ne]

I think this would lead to a hellpit of sycophantic behavior. And, genius or not, I would not trust any group of people to be immune to the influence of the sycophants.

[Kinrany]

Would that be worse than the current disaster though?

[mach1ne]

Not necessarily. Still, a drastic change asks for strong evidence of improvement.

[derbOac]

Honestly your proposal isn't too different from what I've seen going on in many university administrations. My initial reaction is that it is the current disaster.