I once had my phone, which I had turned off, loudly ring during a moment of silence I was attending. It was extremely embarrassing, and until I replaced that phone whenever I was in a similar situation where it was critical to be quiet, I removed the battery. It wasn't that I didn't trust the phone or it's software, but mistakes and accidents happen, and for some critical situations it's better to be safe than sorry.
Same thing applies to phones with hardware switches.
No. You can inspect the hardware. If you can verify that the switch disables the radio, you don't have to worry about software do you?
... unless there is some other way to exfiltrate data, such as:
1. alternative antennae, chipsets?
2. some kind of filtering + buffer + delayed send
3. something else...?
Whatever the case, such techniques are not free of cost and increase the chance of exfil detection. So, killswitches provide a later of protection. Therefore, the claim that killswitches are of _no_ use is not adequately argued above.
> hardware. If you can verify that the switch disables the radio, you don't have to worry about software do you?
Until the next time you turn radio on, when it could just send out anything, anywhere if the software stack is untrusted, so we are back at square one.
I'm aware. You apparently did not notice my point #2 above:
> 2. some kind of filtering + buffer + delayed send
Resources (compute, storage) are needed for filtering, buffering, sending. However, these actions are not "free": (1) they increase the chance of detection later; (2) they require electrical power; (3) they require additional design and testing for the device using them. Isn't raising the cost of breaching security the basic idea?
So my point stands: A hardware kill switch serves as a security layer. I'm not saying it's perfect, but it is not (in general) simply security theater (your point above).
I once had my phone, which I had turned off, loudly ring during a moment of silence I was attending. It was extremely embarrassing, and until I replaced that phone whenever I was in a similar situation where it was critical to be quiet, I removed the battery. It wasn't that I didn't trust the phone or it's software, but mistakes and accidents happen, and for some critical situations it's better to be safe than sorry.
Same thing applies to phones with hardware switches.