Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by airbreather 1293 days ago
I appreciate the tech and effort that went into this, but the assessment criteria could maybe be given a few options to suit individual desires/needs.

(Plus I need one to tell me to stop standing too much, or standing but not moving maybe, after incurring some foot problems due to excessive standing desk use during covid lockdown)

However, my neighbour is a career academic with a PhD in human factors, and just last Friday was telling me he had been searching for statistical validation for twenty years that maintaining "good posture" while sitting was beneficial, and has yet to be able to come up with anything even vaguely statistically meaningful.

His take is, any sitting posture is bad for you, if maintained or preferred excessively.

Seems you are good however, as long as you change often enough to balance out or average out the various "curl up" and "stretch out/arching" positions.

This is unless you have a particular injury, or scoleosis etc and have certain positions you need to avoid.

Otherwise, just slouch around, but change semi regularly.

So it would be good if somehow it could tell you too much curl, too much arch/stretch, or too long in one position, instead of deviation from an absolute. But this starts getting complicated on first inspection.

The desire for "good" posture, along with many other things, falls into the category of "are you telling me something you know, or something that someone told you?".

Question everything.

1 comments

Thanks for taking a look. Currently the "posture detection" is only considering the Y-axis deviation of your right eye from a predetermined baseline value, but if there's enough interest it could be expanded to consider those specific positions. MoveNet, the pose detection model I'm using is capable of that.
Yeah, this would be so cool. Even just as simple as a period of relaxation/curl followed by a period of upright/stretch or something. Love the plugin btw, it's very easy to use, though I can already feel my muscles going in to spasm from being so rigid.

I have trichotillomania. Something that could tell me off for doing that, would be HUGE. I genuinely tie my arms to my arm rests so I can't reach my hair.