Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway294566 1296 days ago
The first example isn't enforcement, it is due diligence and compliance in companies. That does happen, of course, sometimes in a useful way, sometimes to just have some fig leaf to point at in case of a complaint.

Google analytics and Google fonts are regularly enforced, but not by data protection officials. "Enforcement" of those is, as you've said, done by scummy private lawyers, scanning websites and sending expensive letters ("Abmahnungen") en masse. Basically, due to a weird precedent, those lawyers are allowed to give you unasked advice on your wrongdoing and billing you for it. But that is, afaik, a specialty of German law, and mostly limited to stuff that can be fully automated. So while you can scan for a website using Google Fonts, you cannot as easily scan for someone using Office365. Although you might, maybe, get a hint by looking at the DNS MX records.

1 comments

What needs to be true about me and my website to possibly be subject to Abmahnungen? Does my website need to be hosted I'm Germany? Do I need to reside in Germany?
Probably a german address in the imprint. I can't imagine they'd bother with anyone abroad. They're just after easy money after all.
"Probably a german address in the imprint."

Just any adress. Their point is, it needs to be an physical adress - so in case someone wants to sue the website, they have somewhere to send the physical letters to.

In other words, many people got expensive physical letters, to make it in general easier for other people to send them expensive phyical letters.

But yes, as far as I know, this only affects germans. But once we control the EU, who knows.

But if I have no imprint which is a common cause of the Abmahnungen? I am curious because I am a German citizen, but haven't lived there in a long time. Right now I just ignore all of that legal German stuff. What would need to change for me to worry? Moving residence to Germany? The server being there?