Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by techdragon 1301 days ago
So, reducing to the actual difference we have … “not them” and “promises to be different from them” …

As someone using neither of them Im genuinely perplexed why anyone trying to work in this space thinks they have a snowballs chance in hell of long term survival if they don’t have some level of critical mass. If the moment the mass reaches critical and business organisation is needed to deal with the legal and business stuff… this whole debacle is a very hardline open source philosophy shitshow and I fully expect this splinter group to eventually fail with the longer term survival of the parent project now less certain because they lost some of that critical mass right at a crucial moment in their growth towards a sustainable level of business cashflow (which is a necessary evil in order for developers working in any software to make a god damn living and not die starving in a gutter) …

So yeah, please tell me why your promises make you qualitatively better at something I would care about?

If your business/community are getting the bulk of their growth from the community of people being alienated from a much larger, older, platform… it behoves you to not make it harder for people to choose you from the other options as they walk out the proverbial door.

1 comments

> developers working in any software to make a god damn living and not die starving in a gutter

There are many examples of opensource developers receiving full time payment from the community. Krita, Godot, and more all exist long term.

You can earn a living, and respect user freedoms.

See that right there is already a better statement than what I replied to. However it still doesn’t tell me how you intend on being more respectful of user freedoms than the other project. You effectively have to convince me why your ethical stance is the correct one in order to make your project seem better than it’s parent in order to sway me towards choosing it over the older more established project.
Those are all unique projects, not forks.