Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by yowlingcat 1303 days ago
I don't think you can reasonably draw any of the conclusions you've made from the individual statements you've said. User PII being misappropriated is far more likely to come from poor InfoSec practices than from the application layer. Memory safety issues are far more likely to accrete to application layer instability and crashes more than not; now that isn't materially good, but it's apples and oranges.

Then you talk about why "startups need regulation" and the lack thereof is why "the world remains an insecure mess" which is another non sequitur drawn from statements which, while individually correct, would never combine to imply that conclusion.

The world is an insecure mess because some societies have not collectively agreed that it is more expensive to be insecure than secure.

Startups don't "need" regulation anymore than regulation is a cure for any problem. In practice, poorly drafted regulation exacerbates rather than solves the problem it is scoped to solve because it opens the door for regulatory capture based monopolies.

That said, I do agree with parts of many of your individual statements: more effective regulations would be good not just for citizens but for startups and society in general; memory safety oriented code tends to be higher ROI for everyone; the world remaining an insecure mess is a pox on global societies whereupon well deployed investment into secure infrastructure would produced significant ROI compared to the present state of the world.