Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kmeisthax 1304 days ago
The no engagement is kind of the point. Twitter is a massive rave, Mastodon is a quiet houseparty.

If you follow lots of people, use hashtags, and the like; you'll get engagement but not virality - which is, IMO, a good thing.
2 comments
throwaway0x7E6 1304 days ago
not for the journos and activists used to getting thousands of reactions to their hot takes

I'm watching this with mild amusement, knowing that they will all be back, and they will all pay for the checkmark

link
colpabar 1304 days ago
It’s pretty funny that people think those journos/activists would even touch the fediverse after they indirectly turned it into twitter for people they got kicked off twitter.
link
txru 1304 days ago
I think you think the fediverse is far more monolithic than it is. Gab is there, so are a bunch of trans activists. Their content don't intersect.

I don't win if you're unfulfilled in friends and content, you don't lose if I have the most followers. Journalism broadcasting and sourcing is a model that might not work in mastodon, but mastodon doesn't have to be a 1-1 mapping of the existing social uses of Twitter

link
egypturnash 1304 days ago
An NYT writer set up "journa.host", got their face flamed off for unleashing a bunch of journalists into a world where there's a strong culture of putting a content warning on your politics, then got further flamed for saying "wow look how many sites block me now" by linking to a "what instances block my instance" site built by Kiwifarms people. And for hosting right-wing journalists under the aegis of "free speech", which a lot of Masto admins are used to seeing as code for "I will do nothing about letting right-wingers emit hate speech, please block my instance". There's also been news articles about this that have more calls for defederating journa.host resulting from decisions to quote Mastodon posts about this without asking for permission, in contravention of the TOS' of the instances those posts were made on.

They would love to turn it into the new Twitter and it is both hilarious and intensely stressful to see the fights over whether this will happen.

I think this was... Tuesday? The past month, and especially the past week has felt like about six hundred years.

link
willio58 1304 days ago
It’s a good thing for conversation but a bad thing for the system we all find ourselves in, capitalism. Virality has economic value, so the masses will chase it.
link