Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cm2187 1305 days ago
French nuclear power plants...
2 comments

> Assumption 1: no electricity imports

They actually rule that out in their model. It should make things slightly cheaper and easier if the EU nations all do this and trade energy, but it's not required.

They exclude a few other notable things:

> Our limit scenario makes a number of severely constraining assumptions for the purpose of emphasizing what is possible for 100% SWB systems. The bar for clean energy will not be nearly so high in most locations.

Assumption 2: no conventional operating reserve

Assumption 3: no other renewables

Assumption 4: no distributed generation or storage

Assumption 5: no impacts from electric vehicle energy storage

Assumption 6: no demand response, load shifting, energy arbitrage, or peak shaving

Assumption 7: no technology breakthroughs

Assumption 8: no subsidies, carbon taxes, or other financial innovations

These are all good things, they're not predicting or recommending against them, they're just saying they've assumed they don't exist when running the numbers to prove it would work everywhere.

Well, actually more than half of them do not work (at least when it‘s warm. Or cold.)

So Germany had to help out France with energy mostly this year.

They are slowly coming back in online the past few weeks ;)

All the other years France was a net exporter of electricity. But no worries, Germany have plenty of coal to backup those 500 billions renewable.