Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SevenNation 1317 days ago
> The disappointment is that, 14 years after the Bitcoin blockchain was invented, little of this promise has been realised. Crypto’s frenzy drew in talent from bright graduates to Wall Street professionals, and capital from vc firms, sovereign-wealth and pension funds. Vast quantities of money, time, talent and energy have been used to build what amount to virtual casinos. Efficient, decentralised versions of mainstream financial functions, such as currency exchanges and lending, exist. But many consumers, fearful of losing their money, do not trust them. Instead they are used to speculate on unstable tokens. Money-launderers, sanctions-dodgers and scammers abound.

Here's the thing: Bitcoin doesn't need you, Mr. Entrepreneur. It doesn't need your black turtleneck savant charisma. It doesn't need your ambition. It doesn't need your "innovation." It doesn't need your groveling before regulators to build your moat. And most of all, it doesn't need your VC money.

This is a problem for said entrepreneurs and VCs. Because they have turtlenecks beanbags, money, innovation, and groveling just burning holes in their collective pockets - waiting to find an outlet.

But it turns out that "crypto" and "DeFi" do need Mr. Entrepreneur and his merry band of VCs. A lot. Why? Because these are efforts to replicate the existing financial system on the sandy foundation of "blockchain." And that's an expensive business.

Toss in the loosest monetary policy in US history and the recipe is complete. A quorum of charismatic entrepreneurs fleecing gullible VCs and depositors out of fake wealth, tossing it into a big pile, dousing with a liberal quantity of gasoline, and setting the entire thing ablaze.

This may or may not be the end of "crypto," but Bitcoin continues to operate just as before - without the need for exchanges, regulators, entrepreneurs, financiers, or visionaries.

3 comments

> This may or may not be the end of "crypto," but Bitcoin continues to operate just as before - without the need for exchanges, regulators, entrepreneurs, financiers, or visionaries.

Bitcoin absolutely needs exchanges. Sure, it's a self contained decentralized system that could keep churning along without needing anything but computation and the internet, but the day you can't exchange btc for fiat is the day bitcoin goes back to 2010, when it was a curiosity that isn't useful for much of anything. The only reason crypto is interesting to anyone except the most true of true believers is that you can exchange it for real money. What is the point of it without exchanges?

> ... What is the point of it without exchanges?

The point is that exchange of bitcoin for goods and services is possible without trusted third parties. Whether you approve of what is being traded is a separate question.

Here's the thing: the public doesn't need Bitcoin. The public needs quite a few of the services and functions that the existing financial system provides. Bitcoin on its own is unable to provide many / most of these.

The last handful of True Believers can shuffle Bitcoin among themselves indefinitely, this is true. But does that have any more significance to the world than a multiplayer game someone creates for only them and their friends to play, handing game items back and forth among themselves?

What is Bitcoin doing while it operates?
Facilitating the exchange of stored value for goods and services without a trusted third party.