Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by indigochill 1317 days ago
> I’ve got to figure out if it’s really John Doe and that’s a bit of work if I don’t already have John’s public key.

Maybe a dumb question, but assuming a scenario where you have a concept of "really John Doe", isn't there always some authoritative source on what that means that you could use to obtain John's public key (whether that's some user registry, direct contact with John, etc)?
2 comments
max51 1317 days ago
> isn't there always some authoritative source

yes there is, and that's why most blockchain projects that interact with the real world are doomed to fail.

Another classic exemple are those who wants to solve supply chain problems. To put it simply, the robustness or decentralisation of the database is not the reason why your inventory doesn't match what's in the warehouse. It's all human-related problem (eg. theft, losing shit, scanning the wrong item, being scammed by suppliers, etc.).

link
prepend 1317 days ago
I don’t know of an authoritative source. You can pay verisign or commercial entities to track this.

All the blockchain serves as is an agreed upon common entity that isn’t controlled by a particular company.

It would be nice if governments would issue keypairs and serve as an authoritative source. Sadly, I’ve been waiting 25 years.

link