Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JonathanBeuys 1317 days ago
Still sounds far fetched to me.

Do these types of smart contracts exist on Bitcoin?

2 comments

I don't want to be rude, but you're not the only smart person who's thought of counterparty risks. There's tremendous incentive to all sorts of people to break the cryptographic security that secures these networks. And, thus, also incentive to stay ahead of those people.
I'm not very worried about the cryptographic security of the Bitcoin blockchain.

I am worried that in 5 years we will learn that some hardware wallets used side channels to transfer bits of your private key out to make it easier to guess for someone who worked at the manufacturer.

But you can check this. You can monitor whether info is leaving on other channels. And you can sign on an air-gapped computer and transfer only the signed transaction hash (never the privkey) to a connected one to broadcast. You can do all but the actual signature with open source tools.

Just because you haven't taken the time to learn how this stuff works doesn't mean there aren't thousands of incredibly intelligent people who have been working on it for a decade and have actually solved the low-level concerns you have.

You cannot monitor all channels when you use just a single way to create your hashes.

Example: If you use a single hardware wallet to sign your transactions, you have no way to know if the wallet transmits data out via the hashkey:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32181462

They don't need to. Multisig is built directly into the protocol for BTC.

Search BTC multisig and you can learn all about it.

I know Bitcoin multisigs.

But nobody is creating them with pencil and paper.

I don't know what that comment was about. That would be a weird way to do it. I don't know why anyone would want to.