Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by guilhas 1312 days ago
I tried the google camera app on GrapheneOS and can't make it work, in CalyxOS it just works
3 comments

Google Camera works perfectly on GrapheneOS, and unlike CalyxOS runs as a regular sandboxed app. It's as simple as following our instructions and installing GSF from our app repository followed by Google Camera:

https://grapheneos.org/usage#google-camera

You can revoke Network from Google Camera and GSF if you'd like. Google Photos works that way too. None of those need Play services and the Play Store, but you can use Play services and the Play Store as regular sandboxed apps on GrapheneOS. GrapheneOS has MUCH broader app compatibility than CalyxOS and without making the privacy/security sacrifices it does to integrate microG into the OS. CalyxOS has privileged Google services integration built into the OS so you don't need to install anything, but installing apps from our app repository and getting far broader app compatibility with fewer sacrifices isn't a problem for users.

CalyxOS isn't a hardened OS. It substantially reduces security rather than improving it. They roll back the security model and go months without shipping the baseline Android privacy/security updates. They shipped half the August and September security part of the way into October including multiple critical remote code execution vulnerabilities. This happens every year and throughout the year. It's not simply not hardened but not a safe option even for people not focused on privacy/security. Providing proper security updates is the bare minimum. There are still missing security patches with it today, and they're still downplaying and misleading users about it. Just check their recent news posts announcing the August and September updates while admitting they aren't providing half of them. Note: what they say about providing all the open source patches is wrong, since lots of what they skipped was open source, and the updates they skipped were mostly more important than the ones they shipped.

It works flawlessly on GrapheneOS, you can even isolate it from your main profile and run it in a second profile with just GSF. Never had any issues with it.
You didn't try very hard then, I could just install it from play store on my Pixel 6