Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hyperionplays 1310 days ago
Shame Australian's see little to no benefit, all of the profits are off shored and there are little royalties paid back to the Australian people.
3 comments

But all Australians are free to go and earn $200,000pa working in the mines in WA...
Except nobody actually works in those mines, there’ they’re effectively entirely automated.

There were jobs around in the 2010’s during a mining “construction” boom, but once the mines were built 90% of the jobs went too.

Even the trains have been automated, which I assume has been historically difficult only because of unions and safety regulations. A bit easier to pull off in the remote outback I suspect.
Is that you, Clive?

This doesn’t seem very plausible to me. You are proposing that there could have been an alternate universe where, for example, instead of sending iron ire to China for steel production, Australia could have become the steel producer. This has many assumptions - firstly, that China would buy Australian steel as opposed to finding another ore producer and doing what they do now anyway. You also assume that this would be a good business in Australia. Quite possibly, the economics don’t play out due to energy/labour costs.

You're far more correct in that China would far rather buy the iron ore and coal from Australia and make steel in China.

Why? Social stability, and the security of the party. Even if it's less efficient to import the ore and coal, the steelworks keeps people employed, particularly young men who might otherwise grow restive.

I don't get it. Are you disagreeing with the parent comment, or taking it as a forgone conclusion with no plausible alternative?
Disagreeing.
It's not like they're giving the lithium away for free?
After you account for the environmental costs, they are probably paying people to remove it from their country
Isn't that true of almost everything humans do? When I get a tank of gas, I'm basically paying to have a bigger problem in the future. I do so because it solves a problem I have in the present.