Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by User23 1329 days ago
Surely you understand exactly what is meant. Why play dumb? For example I’m not equal to Bobby Fischer as a chess player.
1 comments

I'm not playing dumb. And I'm also surprised that you're so confident that what they meant by equality is "equal skill levels at a particular task." If that's what they meant, there's literally nobody who believes either that everyone is equal at every task, or that everyone is equal at any task. That would be a dumb strawman.

So are you playing dumb, or is that really what you think they meant?

Egalitarianism is such a weak position that there’s no need to strawman it.

And yes literally nobody except children and fools truly believes that people are equal in any material sense. Evidence suggests to me that you are neither a child nor a fool.

Indeed the egalitarian position is so transparently weak that even its erstwhile proponents have abandoned it in favor of “equity,” whatever that means.