Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by exhilaration 1330 days ago
I've read comments on Hacker News that adjustable rate mortgages are the rule rather than the exception in many countries (outside of the U.S.). Here's a comment saying that Canada ONLY does ARMs https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15185052 and another comment saying that they're very common in some European countries: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30339845. I'm guessing this is how it is in New Zealand.
1 comments

Canada does both adjustable-rate and fixed-rate mortgages. Just that we tend to do it for shorter periods. Typically 5 or 10 years.

I have two fixed-rate mortgages with really low rates. They won't come up for renewal until 4 years from now. Then I'll have to choose whether to do another 5 years with the current rate, or convert over to an adjustable rate.

In the US a mortgage with a rate that resets after 5 years would be considered an adjustable rate mortgage, although the rate would typically reset yearly after the initial 5 years (a 5/1 ARM).

A mortgage that ends after 5 years and needs to be renewed would be considered a balloon mortgage, and they are rare in the US. They are "non-qualified" mortgages which means the government sponsored entities won't buy them, so there is a limited secondary market and they have much higher rates.

I don't think I would sleep great at night knowing that every 5 years I would need to either get a new mortgage loan or lose my house.

It seems to be common due to the oligopoly of Canadian banks (there are 5 big banks for all of Canada and the concept of a small bank just doesn't exist, due to regulatory hurdles). It's a way to push the risk onto the consumer and guarantees that homeowners are first to suffer in a downturn - conversely Canadian banks are very "safe" from economic pressures, at least compared to their American counterparts. It's already a big problem because Canadian household debt has reached 2.1 trillion dollars [0], with a GDP of 1.9 trillion dollars [1] (all in USD). Note these figures don't include government debt, which is also significant. Altogether, Canada may face a liquidity crisis on servicing the debt, if rates continue to rise.

[0] https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/canada/household-debt

[1] https://tradingeconomics.com/canada/gdp

Canada doesn't have the concept of fixed-rate mortgages like in the US though, which is where the rate is fixed for the entire life of the mortgage. What you are describing is an adjustable-rate mortgage with an initial 5 year fixed-rate term, which in the US would be called a 5/1 ARM.