Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by matheusmoreira 1324 days ago
> does not mean that it's by any means a settled issue or indicative of "Reality". I doubt these conversations would exist if it was.

It is the reality of computing. Anyone trying to deny that is going to discover that bits are bits and there is no control unless you end computer freedom. It takes tyranny such as mandating that computers only run government signed software to change this reality. This is the sort of thing that will happen if this copyright insanity continues and it will also pave the way to absurdities like regulation of cryptography.

> We need to stop demonizing the idea that someone can benefit from their work

Nobody is doing that. They can benefit from their work as much as they want. Plenty of creators are benefiting right now from patronage via platforms like Patreon. They're getting paid for the act of creating, not for sales of an artiticially scarce product. Copyright is not necessary.

1 comments

The reality of physics and biology is that if someone is bigger and stronger than someone else, they can beat them up and take their things. Anyone trying to deny that is going to discover there is no control unless you end the freedom of unlimited violence. It takes tyranny such as mandating that beating people for no reason and taking whatever they have using the tool of your superior physical strength results in punishment imposed by collective agreement of society.
You're actually comparing these copyright issues to physical violence? I don't even know what to say. They're not even in the same conceptual space.