Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by BoiledCabbage 1329 days ago
You were right, up until you were wrong.

Most peeps looking at this situation ignore (or are unaware) of the first level issue. It's it demand side or is it supply side. Demand side can rebalance eventually and is less harmful. Supply side means everyone is now poorer and it's more painful on top of also including a unequal distribution of that pain.

The 1970s was supply side - driven most significantly by the fallout of the oil shocks.

> The inflation is a consequence of a mistake that has already been made by the Fed - overly expansionary monetary policy since 2021

However you miss the next important level of distinction in inflation. Inflation in what? Basic goods and services or investments/ assets?

People have been claiming that the Fed's policy (and QE) would kick off horrible inflation in goods and services now every year since 2009 and it never happened. When did goods and services inflation start? During the supply side shutdowns of Covid when hundreds of economies worldwide began producing less due to people remaining home, getting sick, retiring early, dying and factories and shops closing.

Then goods and services inflation kicked into high gear with yet again the oil spike. Oil price doubled in roughly 18 months, peaking earlier this year. And yet again we see goods and services inflation.

The inflation that's hitting common families is (as usual) supply driven.

Now is you're a crypto investor, or a real estate investor, or looking to buy a house, or own stocks, then yes you have legit complaint about the demand driven asset bubble and subsequent popping due to the Fed's policy of cheap money. But the reason trips to the grocery store, filing up a tank, and every day costs are more expensive now is due to supply side.

1 comments

It... sounds to me like you're agreeing? What you're describing in the second part of your post is exactly what I mean by supply side inflation. What's your issue with what I said?
I'll step in with a disagreement: CPI is a fact. The attribution to CPI to demand and supply is just a theory. And it's not all that relevant anyway.

The Fed has a job to do by law. Who cares who or what caused the inflation? Powell explains after each FOMC meeting that inflation is bad for the economy, and in order to have a healthy economy the inflation has to be reduced back to reasonable levels, around 2%. And the Fed will raise rates and keep them there until inflation is tamed.

He admits that there's supply side, but he repeatedly said the Fed can only control the demand side, and that's what they are doing.

I don't particularly disagree with any of this from the perspective of the Fed, but that is a different discussion entirely - the distinction *is* crucial for the purpose of answering the original question of 'how is inflation bad'.