Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by qwerki 1324 days ago
Only projects that sign in are receiving funds. thanks.dev only makes money from tips at time of donation. The minimum withdrawal amount is $1 and that's a UI limitation mostly. Good idea re the global blacklist being overridable by the end user!

Hope that clarifies things. Let me know if you have any other concerns. :)
2 comments
e3bc54b2 1324 days ago
> Only projects that sign in are receiving funds.

Are you also only receiving funds for projects that sign in?

Otherwise it seems awful lot like impersonating someone else and withholding money until they finally sign into your platform.

link
qwerki 1324 days ago
Not sure I understand the question correctly, but the way it's working is that Sentry have allocated a monthly budget to be distributed to their dependency tree. That budget gets trickled down to the projects that have signed in. The list and breakdowns are visible here https://thanks.dev/p/gh/getsentry.

Donors decide how much to tip thanks.dev at time of donation.

Please let me know if I missed the question or if I can improve thanks.dev in any way. I'm very keen to learn. :)

link
damagednoob 1324 days ago
If a project never signs in with thanks.dev, what happens to their donations?
link
qwerki 1324 days ago
Donations are only allocated to the projects in the dependency tree that have signed up with thanks.dev. In the Sentry list for example if you click the more link at the bottom you'll see all the projects that hadn't signed in. The ones showing verified next to their name signed in after the funds for this month were processed. I see how this is causing a bit of confusion and will work on improving this aspect asap.

https://thanks.dev/p/gh/getsentry

link
Nemo157 1324 days ago
If you're improving the UI around here it would also be good to see how the list was determined. For automated detection in particular it seems like the tooling used also should be made public to allow testing. I know of at least one dependency that I would expect to turn up on sentry's list that doesn't. (A first guess: a bug in how you handle Rust workspaces, using the root to calculate dependency depth; alternatively a bug in your handling of non-lowercase github usernames, I notice there are only lowercase usernames in the list, but that might just be an artifact of your UI design).
link
stubish 1324 days ago
How does a project sign in? As a developer, I have no idea if you are holding money for my project, or how to claim existing or future funds owing. Everything I see is about analyzing my tree and donating to other people.
link