[ScottyHops]

Discrimination and over-representation could both happen right?

Group A is 5% of the overall population, but 15% of the best admissions to a college, and the college ends up being 10% from group A.

[nemothekid]

Fine, but then the reasoning against Jewish students doesn't stand. How can anyone, except for the Stanford admissions office, deduce whether or not Jewish students are over or under represented?