Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dev_daftly 1334 days ago
Have they separated scroll direction for mouse and trackpad yet? I don't understand how a shared flag like that has not been fixed yet, does nobody at apple use a normal mouse?
3 comments

Doesn't look like it. But Mos still seems to work if that bothers you (as it does me).

https://mos.caldis.me/

I hate the fact that I have to install third party software to do something every other OS (i believe) has as the default. I've been using scroll reverser, but that looks nicer, will try it out. Thanks
It doesn't look like it. There are separate controls on the mouse and trackpad screen, but they're tied to the same value.

I would think that would be separate - the keyboard re-mappings are different for each keyboard that you plug in.

I use a normal wheely mouse and am fine with "natural" scrolling, but I may just be weird in that respect. (I've had really bad luck with bluetooth mice, so my not so magic mice live in my closet.)

> There are separate controls on the mouse and trackpad screen, but they're tied to the same value

That's what killed the "Apple's UX is great and it just works" myth for me after i got my first work issued MBP. Not only is a basic feature lacking, there is stupidly confusing configuration for it in two places that makes you think it exists, but it doesn't. Apple's UI/UX/PM people make stupid decisions, same as any other company.

This isn’t about normal mouse or not, after all the Magic Mouse IS and scrolls like a normal mouse, just with a touch-surface instead of a wheel.

It’s about the fact that in macOS it’s the content that scrolls, not the viewport. By moving your finger up on a touchpad you’re pushing the content up, and the wheel of a non-Apple mouse is a physical proxy of the content.

You may not like the decision, but in my opinion it makes a lot of sense, and I set the mouse to work like this even in Linux.

> You may not like the decision, but in my opinion it makes a lot of sense, and I set the mouse to work like this even in Linux

It's nice to have the option for that, isn't it? Instead of having two toggles in two separate menus change the same setting who knows why.