Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tluyben2 1340 days ago
Can you give me a French audio file of your comment here; my uncle had a stroke and lost his ability to understand english? He lived in France but is native english and somehow his stroke killed his english comprehension a few years ago.

This is a fact and he is disabled as such; you might be young and able bodied but he wants to listen to your comment in French otherwise he cannot understand it.

Nothing is solved in 2022 unless you are native english and don’t have a disability like some form of speech aphasia.

Even captioning is hard in other languages, like OP has to do it in Hebrew which is so much harder than english as you cannot really do auto caption and then change it around a bit like you can do with english.

Not saying that we shouldn’t do it, but it is not solved at all for many cases; you would basically want to pick the language and if you want subtitles or transcript in that language. We can do english (almost) auto, the rest (at least as far as I can read) is pretty crap.

And sure, you can hire a specialised company for it; we are talking about people providing free content and often making nothing or a few cents from that. Most won’t be companies, but private persons filming their hobbies. There is nothing to spend. Companies should put this in their budget, but there should be a startup/grace period: we don’t all have 100m$ investment (and many of these are violators; Airtable was(is?) a good example).