Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by markvdb 1347 days ago
Working for the butcher prince. We don't need that kind of people near any NATO army. Let's hope they stay in Saudi Arabia.

In other news, this is just another symptom of a shrinking US empire. Pax americana is starting to crumble.

5 comments

While I'm in general agreement that we should stop treating Saudi Arabia like it's the ally we want it to be given their actions in Yemen, with OPEC and their direct ties to 9/11.

But your comment is particularly funny because you brought up NATO [1]:

> One typical example is General Adolf Heusinger, a career military officer who, with the outbreak of the Second World War, became part of the German headquarters field staff and helped plan the Nazi invasions of Poland, Denmark, Norway, France and the Low Countries. The Nazis perpetrated against Poland one of the worst crimes history has ever known. Poland suffered the largest number of casualties per capita of any European country, with a total of about six million people killed. Heusinger rose quickly through the Wehrmacht’s administrative ranks and in 1944 was appointed Adolf Hitler’s Chief of the General Staff of the Army.

> With the 1955 establishment of the Bundeswehr, the reconstituted West German Armed Forces, Heusinger returned to military service, and was appointed Lieutenant-General in 1955. In 1957, he was promoted to full general and named the first Inspector-General of the Bundeswehr. He served in that capacity until 1961. In 1961, Heusinger was appointed Chairman of the NATO Military Committee, making him the senior military spokesperson for NATO and in 1963 he also became NATO’s chief of staff, serving in that capacity until 1964.

There were a number of other ex-Nazis in NATO's ranks and leadership.

[1]: https://cpcml.ca/itn220328-tmld-art4/

Generals who oversaw Abu Ghraib are no different.

Pax Americana is definitely crumbling before our eyes.

It's ok for two different things to both be bad, we don't have to pretend they're the same.
They're similar in that they're both beyond the pale.

For example, Manadel al-Jamadi was murdered in detention, while being tortured by the US military. The people who murdered him then took "thumbs up" photos with his corpse.

No one was punished for his murder.

NSFW, his corpse is pictured on this page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Manadel_al-Jamadi

I don't see much of a difference between the two. They're both institutional murder and torture.
There is action and there is the reaction. You could argue that the action is identical. But the reaction—internal, institutional, political—was and is not participating similar.

People in power will abuse power. That’s inevitable in any regime. What makes the difference is how they are held accountable, especially by their own regime.

Under both Obama and Trump the US provided *direct* logistical and targeting support for the Saudi bombing of Yemeni targets. Biden finally stopped it in 2021. The humanitarian catastrophe in Yemen would not have happened without U.S acquiescence.

Saudi Arabia is not a U.S adversary, it is an ungrateful client state and has been since Roosevelt.

> Pax americana is starting to crumble.

You mean Pax Israel is starting to crumble. Is it a coincidence that Yair Lapid is now advocating for a two state solution? They see the writing on the wall.

Crumbling for sure. But incredible turn arounds have happened before. Consider the US posture at the end of the 1970s vs only a decade later.