Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sergiomattei 1338 days ago
I wholly understand your point, but there's a huge power imbalance here. We can run all the referendums we want.

The US government has the full might of the US military, a reluctant political class and an economic interest in keeping the status quo.

There has to be cooperation in both sides for either statehood or independence, if decolonization is to be achieved peacefully. Sadly, there's no will to negotiate from the US gov’t.

About corruption, well, it’s true. Our ex-governor was recently indicted.

However, I also find corruption allegations a convenient way to perpetuate this image of Puerto Ricans as freeloaders—completely missing how much the mainland benefits from us economically, both as a tax haven and as a source of tax revenue (no IRS federal tax, but Jones Act import restrictions).

For more on economic benefits, think about this: a market of 2-3 million people locked in exclusively into US goods and markets due to colonial import restrictions.

Taxation without representation.

1 comments

I thought Puerto Rico residents with income sourced from Puerto Rico didn’t have to file (or pay) US income tax. Is that mistaken?
That's correct! But federal income tax isn't the only way to get taxed.

1) All goods sold in PR have to pass by mainland US ports, raising living costs significantly. This means re-boarding into a US vessel on the mainland, then sailing to PR if coming internationally.

2) We pay other federal taxes (as freelancer, I pay social security tax among others).

3) Related to #1, customs taxes and levies on all goods transported, paid to the US Treasury.

This is an excellent overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_Puerto_Rico