Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vlunkr 1344 days ago
I disagree. the point is that if you're concerned about e-waste, start somewhere besides cellphones.
2 comments

If you care about the environment start somewhere other than e-waste.
I don’t mean this to be facetious, but they pointed out that this is whataboutism, and you, in more or less words, disagreed and said ‘what about this other e-waste that should be dealt with?’

besides this, how many people do you know that don’t have a phone? how often on average do you think people replace their phones?

compare those answers to other tech/machinery that you may be thinking of starting with.

also, finally, the top-level comment here takes a really shallow view of how the world economy works. yes if there was a shortage of these materials, there would be an economic incentive to recycle them properly, but that doesn’t mean that the obtaining of these materials doesn’t have a huge human or environmental cost. just because you can get a material cheaply doesn’t mean there’s nothing wrong with doing it

"Whataboutism" is not always a fallacy. Sometimes it's economic fact.