[sirsinsalot]

You're going around the threads trying to make this a gender issue. It's a valid criticism of anyone.

In this case they happen to be female.

That doesn't mean the criticism is motivated by gender.

Your gender also doesn't excuse you from criticism.

[prvit]

It's not a valid criticism of anyone. Essentially zero people with that kind of work experience have infosec degrees.

It's hard to get a formal degree on a subject which isn't taught anywhere!

For example: HN loves Mudge, who also happened to just leave a CISO post, and also only holds a music degree from Berkelee.

[sirsinsalot]

Another data point, I was reading just yesterday on a HN post about fake qualifications about many male director level people without proper education.

They were criticised too.

I guess we all see the world as we wish.

[prvit]

We're specifically talking about a field where even a decade ago "proper education" was only offered by a couple of schools in the world.

Compsci is not an infosec-related degree.

[thwayunion]

> Compsci is not an infosec-related degree.

The vast majority of the people who invented, built, and maintain all the systems infosec people are deploying had CS or CE degrees. A good CS degree provides an excellent foundation for infosec careers. In fact, at many institutions, the infosec major is very similar to the CS major.

It's not everything you need, which is why a CISO should minimally also spend some time as an individual contributor in an infosec or closely adjacent group.

You're moving the goalposts because your position that CISOs need no education whatsoever in the work they are leading is prime facie absurd.

[Kon-Peki]

25 years ago I asked Gene Spafford why the advanced degree program was being run out of the philosophy department instead of the computer science department, and he replied that it made no sense to be part of the CS department.

That's not to say that a CS graduate is or isn't the ideal candidate for the program (I think he felt that they were). But securing systems and organizations is primarily not a technical problem. You should understand that and understand the reasons why.

[thwayunion]

I'm going to go out on a limb and assert that there are no Information Security departments run by Music departments.

[prvit]

>In fact, at many institutions, the infosec major is very similar to the CS major.

Sure, but the best security programs don't even exist in the same department as CS.

At CMU Information Security is run by the College of Engineering, not by the CS department.

At NYU Cybersecurity is run by Tandon school of Engineering, not by the CS department.

At RIT Computing Security is run by ... the Department of Computing Security.

At JHU Cybersecurity is run by Whiting School of Engineering, not by the CS department.

This is because computer science and computer security are two entirely different disciplines.

[thwayunion]

Um... I can tell you've never spent time in academia ;-)

[sirsinsalot]

Independent of if the criticism is valid, it isn't gender motivated.

I'll agree the criticism isn't valid.

I disagree about the invalid criticism being gender biased or motivated.

The subject just happens to be female. That doesn't exempt them from valid or invalid criticism.

This isn't difficult really.