[moomin]

It definitely _can_ be deterministic, but my experience of pulling down packages without a frozen index is that it rarely compiles. This, inevitably is because the plan depends on the current state of hackage. A combination of “it might pick a different minor version”, “different versions can cause cascading effects”, “many libraries have breaking changes” and “Haskell is extremely unforgiving of potential breaks” makes it very difficult to use without either a) being really good or b) downloading a freeze index. (I download freeze indexes.)

The whole core libraries thing is difficult, in that I can see it’s a real problem for everyone constantly updating their packages (and consuming them), but also that most of the changes are actually good ideas.