[duxup]

I suspect the comment you're replying to is also thinking of other posts, but if so, yes that makes it confusing too. You're response is no less accurate.

Personally I do tire from the <insert pet gripe about X company in the announcement> and general pessimism around HN. I'd much rather hear about what folks think of the specific thing and less about the ongoing conversation about topics surrounding the company. So I kinda get that sentiment.