Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WanderPanda 1345 days ago
How far did we come that a „why“ is offensive?!
4 comments

That is not what they said.
idk about offensive, but "why" questions can come across as more accusatory/interrogative depending on the context/relationship
Why don't you understand that there's nuance and subtlety in human interaction?
If someone who genuinely wanted to question your expertise and intended to offend you asked "why did you choose this algorithm?" you would be justified in feeling offended. If someone who genuinely wanted to learn and didn't intend to offend you asked the same question your offense would in reality be unjustified.

The point is you can only make a judgement based on the context as the article states, intention is often invisible and difficult to communicate. Changing "why" to "how " is one potential way of communicating intention but it's not perfect. People will always make a judgement based on the total sum of the context that conversation might be happening in.