Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by seanherron 1344 days ago
For about $50 US, you can get a 10Gbase-T SFP+ module that gives you a copper port at 10gig within a SFP+ form factor. That, coupled with a cheap Mikrotik switch, is plenty to get started.

Second hand Brocade ICX switches are also plentiful and not too power hungry (but they can be loud).

3 comments

Just a heads up to anyone who does intend to go buy a bunch of those modules.

They run absurdly hot, and they eat a lot of power.

If you don't have very good ventilation then you may find these modules running at well north of 80C. I ended up having to mount a 120MM PC fan and attach some mini-headsinks to them to keep them under 50C. Just sitting on a desk they were too hot to touch.

You may find that the power budget for your small 8-12 port SFP+ Switch isn't enough to run more than a few of these at once. I have an 8 Port Mikrotik SFP+ switch that can only run about 4 of them. The Quad-Port SFP+ NIC I bought from fs.com (Intel XL710-BM1) can only do two.

Expect to also run into issues if you use old, poor quality or mistreated cables. If you bend them too far (trying to get around a sharp corner) - they will work fine at 1Gbit, but just not work at all at 10Gb.

You may find it's a whole lot cheaper (and more reliable) to just get some optical cable and transceivers if you want to go more than a few meters.

For distances less than a few meters DAC cables are often reasonable value.

From personal experience, I'm now leaving the 10G-BaseT transceivers for runs where I can't run optical (like existing in-wall wiring).

Yeah, optics or DAC cables are definitely preferable. I wouldn’t run more than one or two 10G-BaseT units in most switches - but when you have a modem or device that only supports it, it’s a much cheaper way to get connected than buying a dedicated switch.
Woah, the brocade switches might be a very good option. I don't mind it being loud, since my server rack is in a well insulated part of my basement and have had no noise issues even with a couple 2U servers. Thanks for the suggestion!
Depending on how many ports you need, you may get away with an ICX 7150-12. It has 14 fixed Gb copper ports and 2 10 Gb SFP ports. It's fanless and has 12 GbE PoE ports.