Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by torstenvl 1349 days ago
If a person of sound mind wishes to end their life, they should be able to. Forcing someone who is experiencing constant excruciating pain to endure that pain until the natural end of their life is cruel and inhumane.
1 comments

A suicidal person is not of sound mind.
And you're more qualified to determine that over the Internet than the two psychiatrists who evaluated the woman in the article?
First of all, the entire field of psychiatry is very dubious. It's nothing similar to a mature science. They aren't really doing objective evaluations. For example, very often, if you really want to take a medication, you almost certainly can find someone who'd write you a prescription for it. [1]

Also, why would someone's academic qualifications entitle them to essentially sentence a suicidal person to death?

[1]: e.g "Also, if by some chance a psychiatrist doesn’t give a patient Adderall, that patient practically always goes to another psychiatrist, and that next psychiatrist does." (https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/12/28/adderall-risks-much-mo...)

> First of all, the entire field of psychiatry is very dubious.

Your argument goes both ways then, both for those who are pro-euthanasia and those who completely are against it.