Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by viraptor 1353 days ago
Nim's very GC-oriented which just isn't great/usable for the kernel. Yes, you can turn it off and allocate/deallocate manually, but then you barely gain anything on top of C apart from an oop system.

Zig isn't improving correctness too much either. It provides some niceties, but no guarantees around correctness if I understand correctly. It's not trivial - here's a whole post about it https://www.scattered-thoughts.net/writing/how-safe-is-zig/

1 comments

My understanding is that nim's arc memory management strategy inserts frees where it can automatically without being a GC, and that rust actually does something similar in many cases. Nim's arc doesn't handle cycles, and there is a more GC-like orc strategy. Even using only arc (and refraining from cyclic data structures or handling those specially) still seems better than "barely ... anything on top of C apart from an oop system".