Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by themoonisachees 1367 days ago
The short answer is that Wizards Of The Coast has an extremely tight grip on all Magic The Gathering events.

To organize an mtg event, you must use their shitty app, otherwise you cannot be an official tournament, and AFAIK are actually forbidden from calling it an MTG event alltogether. Supposedly this is the nintendo way of doing things where under cover of "quality assurance" and under threat of trademark litigation, you can enforce a very tight grip on your product ecosystem.

The longer answer is that as a judge, OOP has no control over the solution " chosen "by tournament organisers and the org has no control over the solution imposed on them by wotc. Wotc in turn has no incentive to improve their product for a lack of viable competition and here you are.

1 comments

The main value for Eventlink is that WotC tracks the playerbase of each tournament organizer and distributes promotional materials accordingly and awards higher status to larger organizers, so tournament organizers are heavily encouraged to use Eventlink so WotC can see the numbers.

Its not even that WotC has no incentive to improve their program; its more that the people in charge there have actively made the decision to not have certain features because they've decided that the nebulous possibility of abuse is more harmful than the concrete need to have certain features in place in order to fix things. Though the last project manager quit (got fired, if the rumours I've heard are true) and I've had a very long meeting with some of the current guys and they seem very open to change.

There are definitely tournament organizers who do not care about this and will simply run on a different platform, but F2F is not one of them.