Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 3bproblem 1370 days ago
Stripe does this, and Coinbase's move to annual equity grants also has a similar effect. There are a lot of tradeoffs in all directions, but the fundamental one is that the reduction in risk naturally carries an equivalent reduction in ability to participate on the upside (eg table at the bottom here: https://www.aeqium.com/post/a-survey-of-equity-refresh-progr...).

You can also argue that it's not good for employees, because downside is capped (stock goes to $0, you keep your salary) but upside is unlimited (Shopify becomes the next Microsoft, you're still driving a Kia).
1 comments
leoqa 1370 days ago
The reality is that RSUs are a better deal because of the unlimited upside. If my RSUs go to zero, I jump to another company and reset my cost basis- there is actually little risk here beyond the first year lock up.
link
akavi 1370 days ago
That's effectively an implicit call option. You can buy an explicit version on the public market.

The question is "Is the cost of an explicit call option greater than the cost of finding a new job?"

There is some benefit in that with an explicit call option, you have to pay up front, while with job switching, you only incur the cost if the implicit option "expires worthless". But that's balanced by the fact that with the implicit option you're exposed to sector-wide risk (eg, see the current tech-wide turndown), while you're not with the explicit one.

link
gpderetta 1370 days ago
Pretty much. Also with the call option you have to pay the premium (and possibly the rollover cost if for some reason you wanted to match exactly the equivalent RSU schedule), on the other hand if the stock price goes down at worst you lose the premium, while the downside with RSU can be much larger.

In practice it would be foolish to invest a large part of your salary in call options of the company you work for. But for the same reason RSUs are also similarly risky and you should always prefer cash and diversify your risk instead.

Edit: If you buy an at the money call and sell the equivalent put you can reduce the premium and replicate the risk profile of the RSU. But I'm not an option trader.

link