Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dylan604 1373 days ago
Is whiplash something that shows up in some sort of scan that shows definitively yes/no that the patient has whiplash?

If not, then that makes sense why it would be so prevelant of a thing for the ambulance chasers to use

2 comments

Sometimes the muscles are compensating for a new instability in the spine from the trauma, which can be seen, but only with a motion x-ray.

I had a motion x-ray done of my neck that finally demonstrated that my skull slips slightly side-to-side relative to my atlas (C1 vertebra). So what seemed like my muscles overreacting or just me complaining about psychogenic neck pain (or trying to scam the insurance company) was actually my muscular system making sure I don't suffer an internal decapitation.

If anyone's having trouble with the insurance company insisting nothing is wrong because the static x-rays look fine, I cannot recommend highly enough that you look into a motion x-ray. It's very possible that your spine is only fine when it isn't moving, and that's no way to live your life.

I believe it is mostly just pulled muscles in the neck, so pretty hard to diagnose with imaging or that sort of thing.