Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kazinator 1379 days ago
> Python is call by reference. Change my mind.

No need to change your entire mind; just an incorrect definition of call-by-reference.

Passing a value which has reference semantics isn't call-by-reference.

Your f receives x by value. That value is a reference into a boxed object. The x[0] = 1 does not change x; it changes the boxed object.

  >>> def f(x):
  ...    x[0] = 1
  ... 
  >>> a = [ 0, 2, 3 ]
  >>> b = a
  >>> f(a)
  >>> a is b
  True
The f function can do nothing to make "a is b" false.

Under pass-by-reference, assigning to x would do that.

Under pass-by-reference, we can pass a reference to a, such that a can be replaced, without affecting b.

"pass-by {whatever}" refers to the semantics of the parameter and what it receives from the argument expression, and how, not the semantics of the argument object/value.