Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by staticassertion 1381 days ago
Other than libc I'm not sure what else would "almost always" be linked. It's going to depend on the language, but for Go/Rust at least static linking is pretty much the default, and lots of people even link to musl.

For other languages I'd say openssl is probably the next most common.
2 comments
capableweb 1380 days ago
> but for Go/Rust at least static linking is pretty much the default

I don't think that's true for Rust. It defaults to depending on glibc, at least on Linux, and you need to explicitly build with musl to get static binaries.

link
staticassertion 1380 days ago
> , and lots of people even link to musl.
link
capableweb 1380 days ago
Not sure how much clearer I could have been about that I'm responding to the "pretty much the default" part
link
manwe150 1381 days ago
Platform ABI typically specifies that libatomic must be dynamically linked, since otherwise libdl will misbehave. Lots of other common libraries including libpthreads, libm, libgfortran, libquadmath also are frequently linked (though commonly now are linked into libc.so for better system performance)
link
sph 1381 days ago
Those are all glibc or GCC libraries.

There is no platform ABI mandate nor Linux kernel requirement for userspace applications to be dynamically linked to anything. If you can talk to the kernel, you can do anything those libraries can do.

link
manwe150 1379 days ago
The linux kernel forces your application to include the vDSO shared library (by pre-loading it). You can ignore it and talk to the kernel directly, but you cannot get the same performance as you could when using that shared library.

On some architectures, atomics are implemented in the kernel by the vDSO shared library (__kernel_cmpxchg), which is supplied to user via libatomic. You can ignore it, but then you cannot interoperate other code (any which uses libatomic.so) without introducing data-races into the code which were not present in the shared-library version, since they may attempt to execute their atomics differently and thus incorrectly.

link
staticassertion 1381 days ago
Never even heard of libatomic, where is it specified that it's required to dynamically linked? I'm surprised to hear that.
link