Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by themerone 1379 days ago
Our EDI code probably has multiple if blocks for every customer we communicate with.

Implementing EDI is not for the faint of heart. For the variations I worked with, there was little useful documentation, I learned mostly be reading existing code. I would hate to have to start from scratch.

1 comments

I wrote an EDI parser from scratch some years ago (2 to 5, really don't remember). Almost until the end I kept second-guessing myself. It all looked so flimsy.

Eventually I made a second parser that utilized a parser-combinator library (the first one was hand-rolled) and devised extremely detailed property tests that I ran against both parsers. Only then did I feel confident.

Naturally, in production the code crashed on the second day because OF COURSE the senders didn't obey the EDI[FACT] spec and had quirky deviations from it.

Shit like that makes people retire to the mountains and never touch a computer again, man.

I still work in the EDI-parser software but retiring to the mountain has never been more appealing.