[AndrewKemendo]

What you describe above is not what the article is describing.

To be honest the author doesn't do a great job at explaining the difference between meaningful dirty work, eg work that needs to get done in order to actually move the company forward, but nobody at the current company can do it, and trying to resurrect abandonware with no coherent vision or power.

The latter will almost always lose (I've been in similar positions) whereas you can indeed build a serious career around the former.

[zeroth32]

But this was the first case! Very important project for legal compliance, not some sort of abandonware nobody cared about. I had enough skills to put it on track, on official assignment from higher management.

[frobozz]

> on official assignment from higher management.

Unless your line manager authorised the secondment (in which case, why PIP?), it wasn't on official assignment, it was just a personal request from someone who happened to be in a higher management position.

[lostcolony]

Telling the VP to get stuffed, you're only going to do what comes through the proper chain of command, is just going to get you fired immediately rather than PIPed.

Not saying there wasn't a way through this that could have led to a positive outcome, but the key takeaway isn't "do the dirty work", it's "make sure what you're doing has an impact, and has visibility from the people in charge of personnel decisions affecting you". Less work but greater visibility > more work and worse visibility. Part of your job is ensuring visibility or you will get shafted.

[zeroth32]

I dont want to argue about this specific case.

But if direct manager promises pay increase or promotion, it is not binding or "official" as well.

[AndrewKemendo]

Fair enough! My apologies for assuming too much.

Sometimes you just get hosed